EU Commission Draft Report on Rule of Law in Albania: Positive Progress, Yet Challenges Remain

The European Commission has drafted a preliminary report on the rule of law in Albania. It provides a thorough analysis of the country’s justice reform and anti-corruption efforts. The report highlights notable achievements, yet it also identifies critical challenges that need further work.
Justice Reform, Independence, and Accountability
The report confirms that Albania continues to advance its judicial reform. It notes clear progress in strengthening the independence of judges and prosecutors. One key achievement includes the completion of vetting for all first-instance judges and prosecutors. This step has improved overall accountability.
However, challenges still exist. Delays in performance evaluations and concerns over quality remain. Difficulties also arise in appointing non-magistrate members to the High Judicial Council and the High Prosecutorial Council.
The High Justice Inspector operates, but staff shortages limit its efficiency. Albania lacks enough judicial inspectors to meet the demands of the institution.
Moreover, the report raises concerns over increasing political pressure on the judiciary. Though judicial stability has improved, public officials and politicians still try to exert influence.
Anti-Corruption Efforts: Progress by SPAK, Legal Gaps Remain
In the fight against corruption, the report praises the 2024–2030 Anti-Corruption Strategy. Albania has built a solid legal foundation. Still, the Commission points to missing laws on prevention. These gaps weaken the broader framework.
Meanwhile, the Special Anti-Corruption Structure (SPAK) shows real progress. It has delivered results, especially in tackling high-level corruption. The report calls this a “tangible step toward a strong track record”.
However, prevention efforts remain weak. Institutions lack coordination. State Police continues to face corruption risks. The High Inspectorate for Asset Declarations also struggles with transparency. It fails to fully control wealth disclosures and detect conflicts of interest.
Justice System, Media Landscape, and Parliament Face Ongoing Hurdles
Albania still struggles to improve the quality of justice. People face barriers in accessing the courts. Judicial training needs more support. Both financial and human resources fall short. Backlogs continue to grow. No strong measures have yet addressed these inefficiencies.
The media environment also faces setbacks. Media ownership is concentrated. Business groups with political ties influence coverage. The government fails to distribute advertising fairly. At the same time, journalists report verbal and physical attacks.
Legislative processes also face problems. Public consultations often fall short. The parliamentary ad hoc committee on good governance and anti-corruption, led by Fatmir Xhafaj, lacks results. Its working methods and overall impact remain limited.
Constitutional Court and Civil Society: Progress and Pressure
The Constitutional Court continues to function. However, Parliament still refuses to act on some of its rulings. Uncertainty over member mandates also causes legal confusion.
In addition, the mandates of the Ombudsperson and the Anti-Discrimination Commissioner have yet to be renewed.
Finally, civil society remains active. Yet, groups face obstacles in registering. Public funding remains limited.
In conclusion, this draft report serves as a guide for Albania’s next steps toward EU membership. It shows where progress has taken root and where further commitment is essential.
/a.p./




