RTSH.al

New Penal Code/ Supreme Court Chief Sadushi Flags Legal Overlaps, Says Reform Risks Boosting State Power Over Freedom

Sokol Sadushi, chairman of the Supreme Court, presented the institution’s position during a consultative roundtable on the draft of the new Penal Code. He called for a clear and professional review of the drafting process.

Sadushi emphasized that his criticisms do not oppose the reform. Instead, they reflect a professional and moral duty to make the code fairer and more credible. He stressed that justice relies on the quality of legal reasoning, not the speed of law adoption.

He warned that the current draft lacks a comprehensive methodology and does not follow best European practices. The explanatory report mentions the need for reform but does not explain the drafting approach. Institutional consultations have been limited, leaving parts of the code unclear and inconsistent in philosophy.

Sadushi identified five pillars that should guide a modern and fair penal policy. He said unclear definitions of criminal offenses and elements of guilt risk subjective interpretations and arbitrary application. The code may increase state power at the expense of protecting individual freedoms.

He also noted that the draft mixes substantive and procedural provisions and sometimes conflicts with other laws, creating duplications and enforcement difficulties. Including certain traffic violations as criminal offenses adds unnecessary burden to the penal system.

Sadushi underlined that the goal of the penal system is not revenge but reintegration. Punishments should be fair and proportional, applied only when all other means fail. A just system limits state intervention and prioritizes individual rights.

Finally, he urged a transparent and professionally inclusive review of the draft Penal Code. He framed this process as a guarantee of quality, integrity, and coherence, not an obstacle to reform.

Të ngjashme

RTI