Criticism over Draft of New Penal Code; Lawyer Beqiri on RTSH Calls It an Unconsulted Textbook

The Ministry of Justice has presented a new draft of the Penal Code. The document emphasizes rehabilitation, reintegration, and restorative justice over punishment.
Lawyer Idajet Beqiri addressed the draft during a broadcast on Albanian Radio and Television (RTSH). He said the country does need a new code but raised concerns about the drafting process. According to him, the text was prepared without consulting key legal institutions.
Beqiri noted the absence of input from the Supreme Court and the Prosecutor’s Office. He underlined the importance of including these bodies to ensure institutional legitimacy and legal clarity.
He also pointed to what he considers disproportional punishments. For instance, he noted that the law treats 2 grams of cannabis similarly to 2 kilograms of heroin. He argued that such comparisons may lead to confusion and imbalanced sentencing.
Beqiri commented on the structure and volume of the draft. With nearly 900 articles, some extending over two pages, he described it as closer to a textbook than a legal code.
He further called for clearer definitions to distinguish criminal acts from lesser violations. In his view, Albania maintains some of the most severe security measures in the region.
He attributed part of the problem to institutional weaknesses. According to him, lack of enforcement and oversight plays a greater role in crime than the nature of penalties.
Beqiri also highlighted current judicial practices. He said that courts tend to assign prison time in over 90% of cases, including those under investigation. Alternatives such as bail or house arrest, he noted, remain rarely applied.
The drafting group, headed by Arben Rakipi from the School of Magistrates, proposed a structure that separates crimes from misdemeanors. The draft also introduces new categories such as “very serious crime,” which refers to offenses punishable by more than ten years or involving organized groups.
Beqiri called for a legal framework based on institutional experience and legal practice, rather than academic formulations.
/a.p./




