RTSH.al

EC Report for 2024: Albania, Fundamental Justice Reform. Encouraging Results from SPAK

The Commission has published its fifth annual Rule of Law Report, examining systematically and objectively rule of law developments in all Member States on an equal basis. In comparison to the first issue of the Rule of Law Report adopted in 2020, Member States and the EU as a whole are much better prepared to detect, prevent and address emerging challenges. This contributes to the resilience of our European democracies and to mutual trust in the EU. It also contributes to a good functioning of the single market and benefits a business environment that fosters competitiveness and sustainable growth.

Since its first publication in 2020, the report has become a true driver of positive reforms: Two thirds (68%) of the recommendations issued in 2023 have been, fully or partially, addressed. However, in some Member States systematic concerns remain and the situation has further deteriorated. These concerns are addressed in the recommendations of this year’s report. There are no recommendations for enlargement countries in this report as recommendations for these countries are issued exclusively in the context of the annual Enlargement Package.

This year’s report includes, for the first time, four country chapters on developments in Albania, Montenegro, North Macedonia and Serbia. Including these enlargement countries in the Rule of Law Report, the most advanced in the process, will support their reform efforts, help authorities to make further progress in the accession process and to prepare for the continuation of work on the rule of law as a future Member State. 

More than 7 in 10 EU citizens agree that the EU plays an important role in helping to uphold the rule of law in their country, according to a Special Eurobarometer survey published today. Close to 9 in 10 EU citizens consider important that all EU Member States respect the core values of the EU, an opinion stable since 2019. In addition, the feeling of being informed about the EU’s fundamental values has improved significantly in many countries: overall, 51% EU citizens feel well informed about the EU’s fundamental values and rule of law, compared to 43% in 2019.

The 2024 report, as every year, includes a Communication examining the situation in the EU as a whole and 27 country chapters looking at significant developments in each Member State. The report also includes an assessment of last year’s recommendations and, on that basis, provides, once more, specific recommendations addressed to all Member States.

The report covers four pillars: national justice systems, anti-corruption frameworks, media freedom and pluralism as well as other institutional checks-and balances.

Albania has implemented a comprehensive justice reform since 2016, overhauling the entire justice system and enhancing accountability through vetting all judges and prosecutors. However, deficiencies persist in appointing non-magistrate members to the High Judicial Council and the High Prosecutorial Council.

The European Commission’s report raises concerns about public officials’ attempts to interfere with the judiciary. Despite this, SPAK (Special Anti-Corruption Structure) has shown promising results, with an increasing number of corruption convictions. Deep political polarization has undermined parliamentary effectiveness, transparency, and objectivity. The Constitutional Court, however, remains effective in maintaining institutional checks and balances.

The High Inspector of Justice is operational but faces challenges due to vacant magistrate-inspector positions. The transparency in magistrate promotions and transfers, alongside attempts to interfere with the judiciary, are ongoing concerns. The introduction of a modern integrated electronic case management system is still awaited, and the quality of justice suffers from financial and human resource constraints. Procedural delays and unresolved cases persist, requiring further efficiency measures.

A new Anti-Corruption Strategy for 2024-2030 is being prepared, with initial positive results from SPAK. However, specialized authorities lack resources, and the efficiency of anti-corruption efforts is hampered by procedural delays and heavy workloads. The number of corruption investigations, prosecutions, and convictions has increased, but a recent amnesty law raises concerns. Financial investigations and asset confiscations have improved but remain limited in scope. Coordination between anti-corruption institutions and law enforcement is weak, and the High Inspectorate for the Declaration and Audit of Assets faces mandate and resource limitations. Corruption remains widespread, particularly during election campaigns, and preventive measures have limited impact due to a complex legal framework.

Political polarization affects parliamentary work, though the Constitutional Court maintains checks and balances. The legal framework for the Ombudsman and the Commissioner against Discrimination exists but faces operational obstacles. Civil society organizations encounter challenges, including registration and funding issues.

Public and business perceptions of judicial independence in Albania are average, with around 46% of the general population and 45% of businesses rating it as “fairly or very good.” The justice reform since 2016 has restructured the judiciary and prosecution, reformed the Constitutional Court, and introduced vetting, fostering judicial integrity and professionalism while reducing political influence.

Të ngjashme

RTI