European Court of Justice Reviews Italy’s Refugee Return Plan to Albania

For the first time on Tuesday, February 25, 2025, the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg began reviewing Italy’s proposed model for swiftly returning illegal refugees who arrive via the Mediterranean Sea, without entering EU territory. Under the plan, refugees would be relocated to shelters established in Albania. The process aims to clarify whether and under what conditions asylum applications from Mediterranean migrants can be processed and decided upon outside EU territory.
The court’s decision could take several months. This legal process concerns plans initiated by the Italian government under Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni. Italy is the first EU country to establish refugee shelters outside the EU, setting up facilities in Albania since October 2024. In these shelters, Italian authorities are responsible for deciding on asylum requests from refugees intercepted while attempting to enter EU territory illegally, often in search of a better life. The goal of this expedited procedure in a third country like Albania is to quickly return refugees to their countries of origin. Other European nations are closely monitoring such plans.
So far, the model has not been successful. Italian courts have suspended the government’s plans three times since October 2024, and the 66 individuals who were transported to Albania have since been sent back to Italy.
The European Court will examine whether a government has the authority to create a list of safe third countries and if it has the right to establish criteria for classifying a country as safe. The court will also assess whether a country can be considered safe if it is not universally safe and whether courts overseeing the expedited procedures are allowed to use their own information sources to verify the process.
This report is based on information from DW.
/a.p./




